Quality Health Authority

Appeals

If you are a provider and you disagree with a QHA audit finding or a decision on your QHA Certificate, you can appeal. People who took no part in your audit or the decision decide your appeal. It costs nothing to appeal.

What you can appeal

You cannot appeal to QHA about the Director-General of Health’s certification decision. The Director-General decides certification, and QHA cannot comment on or support an appeal about that decision. We tell you of any route open to you with the Ministry of Health. You can reach HealthCERT on 0800 113 813 or certification@health.govt.nz.

Before you appeal

If you disagree with a draft finding, raise it first with the lead auditor, with your supporting evidence. Do this during the audit, or within the period stated in your Audit Plan. The lead auditor and the Chief Auditing Officer consider it and record their decision.

How to appeal

If you remain dissatisfied, lodge a written appeal with the Chief Operating Officer within 20 working days of the decision. Use the Appeal form (QHA-RQ-F3), or send a letter or an email.

There is no fee to lodge an appeal. QHA will not treat you less favourably because you appealed.

What happens next

  1. Within five working days, the Chief Operating Officer acknowledges your appeal, records it in the complaints and appeals register, and passes it to the Chair of QHA’s Board.
  2. From the acknowledgement until the panel has decided, the Chief Operating Officer tells you in writing where your appeal has reached, at least every 10 working days. The reports end when we send you the written decision and reasons.
  3. The Board Chair convenes an appeals panel of at least two people, none of whom took part in your audit or the original decision. Where too few directors are free of involvement, the Board appoints an independent senior auditor from outside your audit team to the panel.
  4. Each panel member first declares any conflict of interest. The panel reviews the evidence against the standard and records its work.
  5. Within 20 working days of receiving your appeal, the panel decides and gives you written reasons. Its decision is final within QHA.
  6. If the panel changes a finding, the Chief Auditing Officer corrects the Report and, where it has been submitted, tells HealthCERT.
  7. We record the outcome in the complaints and appeals register and report it to the Board each quarter. The Board reviews trends each year.

If you are still not satisfied

You can still raise concerns about a Designated Auditing Agency with HealthCERT at the Ministry of Health. You can also complain to us about how we handled your appeal.

What we keep